Skip to main content
Tag

gala

When You’re Always Giving: Why Nonprofit Leaders Need This Moment

By Feature

Written By Stefany Dolan for Leadership Johnson County

If you spend your days in the nonprofit world, you know something to be true: fulfilling the mission doesn’t neatly clock you in at 9:00 a.m. and out at 5:00 p.m.

It follows you home. It sits with you at dinner. It wakes you up at 2:00 a.m. when you’re thinking about the family you couldn’t quite help, the funding you’re still trying to secure, or the team member or volunteer who is one hard week away from total burnout.

Nonprofit work is deeply meaningful, rewarding, and impactful—but it’s also very demanding. And somewhere along the way, nonprofit leaders graciously accept this rhythm that leaves very little room to pause, reflect, or feel celebrated.

This is what makes moments of recognition so powerful. The team at Leadership Johnson County has seen what happens when you intentionally create space for nonprofit leaders to step away from the day-to-day and simply be. The focus shifts from output to reflection. Whether it’s framed as a gala celebrating Peace, Love & Gratitude or something else entirely, the heart behind it doesn’t change. It’s about reminding those who give so much of themselves that there is still space for connection, reflection, and a little joy.

These feelings don’t come from the live music, delicious food, or the fun, themed outfits. They are felt because, for a brief moment, nonprofit leaders are invited to step out of the constant giving of themselves and simply receive.

One of last year’s gala attendees, Sonya Ware-Meguiar, Executive Director of Girls Inc. of Johnson County, described the experience this way, “It was truly a magical evening. I felt like I was treated like Cinderella for the evening… It was truly a night to remember. It was so refreshing to be able to just relax and have fun.”

There’s something beautifully human about that sentiment. Beneath the titles, responsibilities, and weight of leadership is a person who just needed a moment to breathe and be showered with gratitude.

Why Recognition Matters More Than We Admit

In many sectors, recognition is built into the culture—bonuses, promotions, awards, public praise. In the nonprofit world, recognition often takes a back seat to mission. There’s always more work to do, more people to serve, and more needs to meet.

But when recognition is absent, something subtle begins to happen.

Leaders start measuring their worth only by outcomes. Teams begin to move from passion to pressure. The quiet, steady impact they’re making can start to feel invisible or unimportant.

That’s why intentional moments of celebration matter so much. The goal of the gala is to remind nonprofits leaders that their work is seen and valued.

“Not knowing what to expect at the beginning, this event went up and beyond anything I could have imagined. It was an extraordinary experience to feel truly honored and appreciated for the work we all do… to feel special, seen and valued,” shared Kendee Kolp, CEO of Reach for Youth, Inc.

Those words carry weight, especially in a field where so much work happens behind the scenes.

A Rare Opportunity to Pause

There’s a common thread when nonprofit leaders reflect on moments like these: it’s not just about being honored, it’s about being able to stop and be still.

In that stillness, something important happens—reflection.

“For me personally, it’s a chance to reflect on the impact of that work—not just in numbers, but in lives changed, both human and animal. It’s about honoring ALL the non-profit teams that show up every day with heart, even in the most challenging moments. This event reminds us that while the work is hard, it is also deeply meaningful, and it deserves to be celebrated,” described Anne Sutton, Executive Director of the Humane Society of Johnson County.

In a world driven by metrics and outcomes, reflection can feel like a luxury; in reality, it’s a necessity.

When leaders take time to reflect, they reconnect with their “why.” They remember the faces behind the numbers and regain the energy needed to keep going.

The Power of Being in the Same Room

Another often-overlooked gift of these moments? Community.

Nonprofit leadership can feel isolating. Even in a room full of people, the weight of decision-making, responsibility, and service can create a sense of standing alone.

Now in its third year, this gala has become more than a single evening—it’s a growing tradition that nonprofit leaders can count on. A moment that continues to bring the community back together, year after year, to reconnect and recharge. Leaders are reminded of something they don’t always have time to see in the day-to-day.

“The Glitter & Gratitude Gala reminds me of what a wonderful community we have with so many individuals giving back and supporting one another,” Sonya Ware-Meguiar shared.

That reminder matters. The nonprofit ecosystem was never meant to function in silos—it thrives on shared purpose, mutual encouragement, and the understanding that no one organization carries the mission alone.

Creating Space for Joy

Joy isn’t a word that gets enough attention in nonprofit work. Joy comes from connection, laughter, and simply being present.

“Those who spend their lives serving others rarely pause to be celebrated themselves… Glitter & Gratitude creates a beautiful moment for nonprofit leaders to step away from their work, enjoy a night of music, fellowship, food, and encouragement, and feel the appreciation of the community that we are honored and humbled to serve. The event is a blessing beyond measure!” last year’s attendee, Kimberly Smith, Executive Director of Johnson County Senior Services shared.

Joy isn’t a distraction from the work—it’s fuel for it.

When leaders experience joy, even briefly, it provides restoration. It softens the edges of burnout. It reminds them why they started in the first place. It gives them something to carry back into the hard days.

Perhaps, most importantly, it reinforces a truth that’s easy to forget: You can be deeply committed to your mission and still allow yourself to feel joy.

More Than a Moment

The impact of the Glitter & Gratitude Gala doesn’t end when the lights go down.

It shows up the next morning when a leader walks into their organization a little lighter. It’s in conversations with their team, where appreciation becomes more intentional. It provides renewed energy, fresh perspective, and a deeper sense of connection to the community they serve alongside.

Moments like these don’t solve every challenge, but they strengthen the people who are solving them. In the nonprofit world, that might be one of the most important investments we can make.

A Simple but Powerful Reminder

At its core, the message is simple: Nonprofit leaders are human.

They are passionate, driven, and resilient—but they are also people who need encouragement, recognition, and moments of rest.

When we create space for that, whether through a gala, a handwritten note, a conversation, or a shared moment of gratitude—we’re helping leaders strengthen their mission.

When leaders feel seen, valued, and connected, they don’t just continue their work, they lead it with greater heart. That kind of leadership has a ripple effect far beyond any evening and deeply imprints on our communities.

Cheers to nonprofit leaders!

This year’s Glitter and Gratitude Gala will be held Tuesday, April 14th at The Sycamore at Mallow Run, in Bargersville.

More Than a Gala—A Tribute to Johnson County’s Nonprofit Heroes

By Feature

Beau Jackson, Modern Woodman of America and Leadership Johnson County

In the world of nonprofit service, recognition can be rare. Long hours, unwavering dedication, and tireless efforts often go unnoticed as leaders focus on supporting their communities. That’s why the Glitter & Gratitude Gala was created—an evening dedicated solely to celebrating those who give so much of themselves.

On Tuesday, April 15, 2025, nonprofit professionals and community champions will gather at The Sycamore at Mallow Run for the 2nd Annual Glitter & Gratitude Gala, embracing the elegance of a Black and Gold Masquerade Ball. With an evening of fine dining, entertainment, and heartfelt recognition, the gala is a night designed to honor the nonprofit leaders who make an immeasurable impact on their communities.

A Celebration Born from Experience

The vision for this event came from Beau Jackson (Greenwood), who spent over 15 years in the nonprofit sector before transitioning into financial advising. One moment in particular stood out—

“While attending a fundraiser with one of those leaders and her husband, I was struck by her comment; seemingly out of nowhere, ‘So this is what this feels like?’ she said to me, smiling. She went on to explain how she never has the opportunity to enjoy these events. She is often the one putting them on and dealing with the stress that comes with such events. I knew right then I wanted to do something special for her and the rest of the nonprofit leaders in our community. I wanted to throw a gala, a party just for them—an evening to celebrate and honor these amazing individuals who may often go unthanked and at times undervalued. I was fortunate in that my LJC (Leadership Johnson County) group was just as crazy as I was to take it on.”

Through Leadership Johnson County’s (LJC) Signature Program and in collaboration with Modern Woodmen’s home office out of Rock Island, IL, Jackson and a group of dedicated Community Champion members made that vision a reality. The inaugural gala was a resounding success, recognizing nonprofit leaders with awards such as the Lifetime Achievement Award and Catalyst of Hope Award, with honorees including Nancy Plake (United Way Johnson County), Tandy Shuck (Leadership Johnson County), and local advocate Rafael Sanchez.

An Evening of Recognition and Elegance

This year’s gala promises to build upon the magic of its inaugural event, offering an unforgettable evening filled with:

  • A formal dinner and drinks to honor attendees in a grand fashion.
  • Dancing and entertainment, bringing joy and connection to the evening.
  • Inspiring speeches that uplift and celebrate the spirit of service.
  • The presentation of prestigious awards, recognizing outstanding nonprofit leaders.

Unlike traditional nonprofit gatherings, this event is not a fundraiser. Instead, it’s a completely free celebration for nonprofit professionals to pause, reflect, and enjoy the recognition they deserve. Each organization is invited to send two representatives—whether a nonprofit leader and their guest or two key team members.

A Growing Community of Support

While the gala was initially founded by Beau Jackson, Julie Ward, Emily Broderick, Bob Fish, Zach DeWitt, Stacy Conrad, and Erika Janik, this year’s event has seen even greater community involvement. Stefany Dolan, working alongside her sister Stacia Jones and their company, becauseOne, has played a key leadership role, managing public relations and designing the event’s program. Michelle Badolato, a Fraternal Champion, has taken on a pivotal leadership role, while Whitney Habig and her company, RootedDesigns, will bring elegance to the evening with stunning floral arrangements. Pat Enoch, enjoying her retirement, has generously stepped in to support the event wherever needed.

A Night of Thanks and Celebration

At its heart, the Glitter & Gratitude Gala is about acknowledging the immeasurable contributions of nonprofit leaders—those who work behind the scenes to uplift their communities. The event stands as a reminder that their hard work is seen, valued, and deeply appreciated.

Mark your calendars for an unforgettable evening of recognition, joy, and community. For one night, the givers become the celebrated.

The 2nd Annual Glitter & Gratitude Gala

  • Date: Tuesday, April 15, 2025
  • Location: The Sycamore at Mallow Run
  • Theme: Black and Gold Masquerade Ball

Special event season is here! What’s next?

By Sponsor Insight

by John Mainella and Michael Pettry, principals, Cape Fletcher Associates and consulting partners of CICF

The season of special events is squarely upon us in Central Indiana. Whether springtime galas, summer golfing events or the increasingly popular breakfast fundraiser, most organizations are in the midst of special event season.

But special events are a lot of work. Then again, you already know that no doubt.

Here’s where many not-for-profits leave tremendous opportunities on the table. After all the work that brings a special event to life, they forget that the actual value of the event likely lies in what happens following the event. Which existing donors made a second-mile gift or increased their giving level? (A move up the giving tiers!) Who made a first-time donation to the organization? (A candidate for renewal and increased giving!)

We recently had a conversation with an executive director lamenting about all of the time and energy that went into planning and executing an event but forgot to invest intentionality and strategy into what happens in the days and weeks after the event.

Whether you are a seasoned staffer, just starting your journey in development, or a stalwart board member, here are three suggestions to increase the longer-term benefits of your special events.

Record event attendees into your database and segment this group. Organizations use databases for many reasons, but one is especially important: to grow the base of support. Even though a donor may have given at a special event, they should be added to your database and segmented into their own category.

For the next year or so, use this segmentation strategy when you want to communicate with or solicit the constituency. A good rule of thumb to remember is that the likelihood of retaining a first-time donor increases if you make seven touchpoints with them in the first year.

Impact, impact, impact. The donor likely made a contribution at the event as a result of an extraordinary and emotional appeal to support your mission. In the days and weeks following their gift, make sure that you show the donor the impact of their giving. Consider your first touchpoint be a thank you note sent 24 to 48 hours after they donated their gift.

Next, a month after receiving their gift, text or email them a quick 60-second impact video highlighting the work that their gift made possible. Check out this recent study from the Lilly Family School of Philanthropy about the power of video in donor engagement. That subsequent follow-up is a chance to remind them why they gave at your event and show them that you are already putting their gift to work.

Engage them differently. Don’t assume that you will see the donor at next year’s event. Organizations often see a relatively high turnover rate from year to year for attendance at events. But this doesn’t mean special event donors aren’t interested. When we think of the rule of seven touchpoints to retain a donor, build a strategy using your segmentation to keep your event donors engaged throughout the year.
Add them to your quarterly newsletter mailing list. Consider a personal phone call recognizing the six-month or one-year anniversary of their special event gift. Send an email several weeks before the next event with a “Hope to see you there!” theme. Even though the message isn’t overtly asking for a gift, make sure to include a link for donation for people who aren’t able to attend the event.

At the heart of building your culture of philanthropy is a commitment to establishing meaningful relationships with donors and prospects. Of course, special events play a unique role in building relationships with both constituencies, but it is the wise and artful institution that embraces the fact that special events are only the first chapter of a long and meaningful donor relationship.

Founded by principals John Mainella and Michael Pettry, Cape Fletcher Associates employs sound philanthropy practices and effective communication strategies to grow your base of support.