Tag

benefits

Why Indiana Nonprofits Are Taking a Collaborative Approach to Benefits

By Sponsor Insight

Healthcare costs have become one of the most significant financial pressures facing nonprofit organizations and show little sign of easing. Medical trend is projected at 7% to 8%, while pharmacy trend is expected to reach 13% to 15%. Pharmacy spending now represents approximately 30% of total healthcare costs, driven by specialty medications, expanding use of GLP-1 therapies, growing behavioral health demand and continued provider consolidation. [Aon Global Medical Trend Rates Report 2026]

For nonprofit leaders, these numbers carry implications far beyond annual renewal discussions. When benefits spending grows faster than revenue, the effects can be felt throughout the organization, influencing recruitment and retention, staffing plans, compensation strategies, reserves and program investment.

Why Traditional Cost Management Is Producing Smaller Returns

For years, many organizations managed rising healthcare costs through plan design changes. Deductibles increased. Employee contributions rose. Cost-sharing became more common.

Those approaches can provide short-term budget relief, but they have limited influence over the forces driving healthcare inflation today. Specialty pharmacy spending continues to outpace medical trend. New therapies enter the market at higher costs. Healthcare provider consolidation continues to affect pricing.

Many nonprofit leaders are now examining whether the way benefits are funded and purchased deserves the same level of strategic scrutiny applied to major investments, facilities planning and long-term financial management. That shift in thinking is driving interest in alternative funding structures that may offer greater predictability and purchasing power.

Exploring Available Options

Before evaluating any single structure, it helps to understand how many options exist, because headcount determines which market an organization buys into.

For nonprofits under 50 employees, which includes many Indiana organizations, the default is often a fully insured community-rated plan where premiums are driven largely by factors outside the organization’s control. Alternatives can include grandfathered plans, alternate funding arrangements, association plans and MEWAs, PEO arrangements, and exchange-based coverage through an Individual Coverage Health Reimbursement Arrangement (ICHRA). Each offers different levels of flexibility, administrative support and financial accountability.

Above 50 employees, the range expands to include level-funded and self-funded strategies such as captives, direct self-funding and reference-based pricing. The tradeoff typically becomes predictability versus control, with the right approach depending on claims experience, reserves and risk tolerance.

Yet many nonprofit leaders never see the full range of options presented side by side. As a result, organizations often renew within a narrow set of choices while cost pressures continue to build. One of those broader options is now available in Indiana for the first time.

A Different Model for Indiana Nonprofits

One structural option Indiana nonprofits now have is the Indiana Nonprofit Benefits Trust, the state’s first Multiple Employer Welfare Arrangement (MEWA) built exclusively for nonprofit organizations.

The Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA) defines a MEWA as an arrangement that allows employers outside the same control group to participate in a pooled health plan, provided they share a work-related common bond. For this Trust, that bond is nonprofit status and membership in the Indiana Philanthropy Alliance. Participating organizations join a single pooled arrangement rather than purchasing coverage as individual small groups.

Pooling changes the rating conversation. Small employers in the traditional market are frequently community rated, with premiums driven by age bands and factors outside their control. Inside the Trust, organizations are rated as part of a larger group with stable pricing that is not age-banded. Claims volatility is spread across the pool, so a single high-cost year at one organization does not land entirely on that organization’s renewal.

The Indiana Department of Insurance approved the Trust in late 2025 following an 18-month collaboration among Welborn, NFP, Indiana Philanthropy Alliance and a founding group of nonprofit organizations. Those organizations helped shape and test the structure before launching, ensuring it reflected the realities of nonprofit budgets and operations.

Underneath the mechanics sits a straightforward observation. Indiana nonprofits face remarkably similar workforce and healthcare pressures, including the challenge of offering competitive benefits to attract and retain talented employees, and most have been absorbing those pressures independently.

Why the Partnership Matters

The collaboration that produced the Trust should look familiar to anyone working in this sector. Shared services, collective funding and coalition advocacy exist because certain problems respond better to collective effort. Employee benefits may be becoming another area where collaboration can create value.

What that collaboration produced is a network, not just a rate. IPA membership is a condition of joining, and the requirement was intentional. As Indiana’s statewide network for philanthropy, IPA advocates at the state and federal levels on issues affecting the sector and brings organizations together around shared challenges and opportunities. Nonprofit members participating in the Trust can also take part in select IPA convenings and resources relevant to their work, creating opportunities to connect with others across Indiana’s philanthropic and nonprofit communities.

Those opportunities acknowledge something experienced nonprofit leaders already understand: workforce challenges are rarely solved through benefits alone. Sustainable solutions often require organizations to examine leadership, culture, financial strategy and employee experience together.

The plan itself is built the same way, with support for the people who administer it and the people who use it, including online enrollment, dedicated member support, pharmacy savings programs, virtual care and wellbeing resources. For organizations that have spent several renewals managing costs through reductions or increased employee cost-sharing, access to additional services and support can help shift the benefits conversation.

What Leaders Should Be Thinking About Next

A collective purchasing model will not be the right answer for every nonprofit. Workforce demographics, organizational size, claims experience, financial objectives and risk tolerance all point in different directions, and the appropriate structure depends on facts specific to each organization.

Nonprofit organizations have more options than many realize, and the Indiana Nonprofit Benefits Trust represents one Indiana-based response to rising healthcare costs. More broadly, it reflects what the nonprofit sector has long done well: working together to address shared challenges in ways that can strengthen individual organizations and the sector as a whole.

At NFP, we believe leaders make stronger decisions when they understand the full range of available strategies. Whether that means a MEWA, a fully insured plan or another approach, the objective remains the same: helping Indiana employers support and retain the people who carry out their missions while protecting the financial resources that make that work possible.

If this article sparked questions about your organization’s benefits strategy, we’d welcome a conversation. Reach out to Anna Beaty (anna.beaty@nfp.com) or email INnonprofittrust@nfp.com for more information.

Is it time to take a break?

By Feature

Lilly Endowment renewal programs highlight benefits of rest

by Shari Finnell, editor/writer, Not-for-profit News

(As nonprofits seek ways to encourage employee retention, enhance recruitment and minimize burn out, Not-for-profit News explores the benefits of Lilly Endowment’s renewal grant programs in this first part of a two-part series.)

As a long-time dedicated nonprofit employee, Angie Hoskins understands first-hand the symptoms of employee burnout. In 2019, her stress levels hit a peak as she took on additional responsibilities at Easter Seals Crossroads during a critical transition in roles.

“I was juggling two different positions with no end in sight,” said Hoskins, who is a benefits specialist technical assistant for the nonprofit organization. “I was being pulled in several different directions and working a lot of extra hours during a transition.”

Her concerned supervisors urged her to apply for a grant through United Way of Central Indiana’s (UWCI) Human Services Professional Renewal Program, Hoskins recalled. Under the program, which is now in its 20th year of being fully funded by Lilly Endowment, offers up to $10,000 each to up to 25 human service professionals each year to pause from their day-to-day responsibilities to explore their passions and new ideas. Lilly Endowment funds similar programs for teachers, clergy, artists and art administrators.

Hoskins’ grant request to explore her genealogy by touring Ireland was approved. However, COVID-19 travel restrictions related to international travel in 2020 forced her to make a change in plans. This year, she traveled to Alaska with her husband, Shane Hoskins, for a cruise and land tour. 

After returning to Indianapolis, Hoskins said, she experienced a renewed sense of purpose. “This trip was much needed. I came back not expecting how revived I would feel. I was excited to do my job again,” she said. “It also gave me the opportunity to step back and recognize how many people I’ve been able to help.”

Going beyond recognition

Julie Koegel, program coordinator for UWCI’s Human Services Professional Renewal Program, said that the benefits of the program extend beyond acknowledging an employee’s dedication to their nonprofit work. They can prove to be a motivating factor for retention and innovation among employees in the field, she said.

Nonprofit work can be demanding for many employees, Koegel pointed out. “They’re often working long hours. Some of them are on call 24/7. Some are missing their own kids’ activities because they’re going to the activities of the children they serve,” she said. “People get burned out. During COVID, in particular, it’s been really hard because these individuals have been first responders; among the first ones being called for assistance.”

“We wanted to make sure people who have been working in this field for 20, 30 or 40 years are able to experience renewal,” Koegel added. “We also want to recognize those who are younger, who haven’t been working in the field as long. We want to keep them in the field.”

Recognizing nonprofit employees at all levels

According to Sara VanSlambrook, chief impact officer for UWCI, the grant renewal program is an important way to recognize nonprofit employees who often don’t qualify for other recognitions. 

“Too often, frontline managers and staff are overlooked,” VanSlambrook said. “Awards and recognition are often targeted to executive directors. This program is for anyone at any level within an organization. About 45 percent of the grantees over the years have been frontline staff.”

Renewal grant recipients have included employees ranging from executive directors, vice presidents and managers to receptionists, cafeteria workers and correctional officers, she said. 

VanSlambrook also said that these types of benefits in the workplace can be critical for retention.

“It communicates to human service professionals that they are essential workers, and that we value them,” she said. “It reduces stress levels for those who receive it. It brings new energy and creativity to the work upon returning from an investment like this. They usually come back with new ideas and new knowledge that will enhance their work.”

Applicants of the UWCI Human Services Professional Renewal Grant program must meet the following criteria:

  • Must be an employee of a UWCI agency, UWCI, or an invited human services organization that is actively engaged in a UWCI collaborative activity
  • Must have been employed eight or more consecutive years by a human services nonprofit agency as of the application deadline
  • Must have been employed by their current organization five or more consecutive years as of the application deadline
  • Must serve clients in the UWCI areas of service: Boone, Hamilton, Hancock, Hendricks, Marion and Morgan counties
  • Must intend to remain in human services work for at least two years after the renewal experience

Over the years of administering the program, Koegel said, she has seen it accomplish its mission among the participants. “They come back to their jobs renewed, with new perspectives,” she said. 

She also said an evaluation revealed that numerous participants said they probably would have left their jobs if they had not experienced the period of renewal offered under the grant.

“They had reached that point where they were so burned out that they were looking at other opportunities,” Koegel said. “This gave them a chance to take a step back, to have permission not to answer their voicemails, not to look at their emails, and to really disconnect for a period of time and really focus on themselves.”

The overlooked benefits of outsourcing nonprofit accounting

By Sponsor Insight

By Jim Simpson, CPA and director, Financial Technologies & Management

In the nonprofit community, outsourcing typically means long-term delegation of key operation to outside experts. The accompanying expectation is improvement of the quality, strengthening effectiveness, and lowering or controlling costs.

A key difference in the nonprofit sector is not only controlling costs, but becoming a more effective organization. Finance and accounting departments are two essential back-office areas in nonprofit organizations.

With limited resources, a nonprofit can outsource some or all its financial functions, which can help a nonprofit efficiently staff and conduct its financial operations. It also respects the board and executives limited time or expertise to manage the finance functions, and allow more allocation of resources toward mission and program outcomes.

Here are six overlooked, and sometimes unknown, benefits of outsourcing nonprofit accounting.

Button Text