By Bryan Orander, Charitable Advisors

Nonprofit boards appear to be taking a more active role in leadership changes, with anecdotal evidence suggesting an increase in board-initiated departures of executive directors and CEOs. In some cases, public announcements point to a board’s decision to pursue a new direction without the organization’s current leader. Leadership transitions were once quieter and handled behind the scenes.

The trend raises questions about the current environment and the increasingly complex relationship between nonprofit CEOs and their boards.

During an early November meeting of the Indiana Nonprofit Consultant Community, participants discussed several factors that may be contributing to greater leadership instability. They generally agreed that more boards include first-time members who bring valuable perspectives but have limited governance experience. At the same time, the line between board oversight and staff leadership can blur, particularly when expectations for the CEO are not clearly defined.

Financial pressures add to the challenge. Over the past 18 months, nonprofits have faced government funding cuts, rising operating cost and increased competition for foundation grants. Boards understandably want answers and accountability, but even effective CEOs cannot control these external conditions.

When financial challenges collide with unclear expectations and limited communication, organizational struggles can quickly become questions about CEO performance. In some cases, replacing the leader may seem easier than identifying and addressing underlying operational or governance problems.

Historically, studies have estimated that about 15% of nonprofit CEO departures are initiated by boards, a figure consistent with what some consultants have observed in their work. Leadership changes are sometimes necessary, but stronger governance practices can help reduce unnecessary or unplanned transitions.

Five practices can help boards strengthen governance and their relationship with the CEO:

  1. Recruit board members with clear expectations. Be upfront about the time commitment, engagement, financial support and responsibilities required. Seek members who are committed to the mission and willing to work as a team. Consider whether a smaller board of engaged leaders could be more effective.
  2. Provide meaningful board orientation. Help new members understand the organization’s mission, finances, and current challenges, as well as the distinction between governance and management. Board members need to be equipped to talk about the organization and understand their roles. Consider having them observe or participate in the work alongside a staff member. Assign an experienced “board buddy” for the first few months to help new members get established and engaged in a committee.
  3. Establish annual goals and evaluate the CEO. In our experience, fewer than half of CEOs receive an annual performance evaluation. A new board chair stepping into this situation should not put it off further. Start with a discussion of goals for the year ahead and agree on the format and process for the annual review. Don’t assume the evaluation form from a Fortune 500 company is the answer. Agree on priorities and performance expectations, schedule regular check-ins and conduct a meaningful annual review.
  4. Invest in ongoing board development. Community board training classes can be a great resource, but they often are held during the workday, and many board members don’t make time to attend. Look for ways to bring a few minutes of thinking and discussion into every board meeting, whether on strategic topics such as the people you serve or on best practices in board operations. Board members need to be familiar with governance, financial oversight, fundraising and effective board-staff relationships.
  5. Keep communication between the board chair and CEO active. Encourage regular, candid conversations so concerns can be addressed before they escalate. It is common for CEOs to meet monthly with their board chairs to think together and ensure no surprises. I know organizations that include the past and next board chairs in those conversations. I also know of organizations where the board chair and CEO meet weekly, which I would suggest is too frequent and risks drawing the chair and board into operational direction and oversight.

Good governance does not eliminate difficult decisions or excuse poor performance. However, clear expectations, informed board members, and a strong working relationship between the board and CEO can help nonprofits navigate challenging circumstances without unnecessary leadership turnover.

In an increasingly demanding nonprofit environment, boards must remember that effective leadership is a shared responsibility. Strengthening board governance may be just as important as choosing the next CEO. Make sure your CEO is set up to succeed.